In North Carolina, as in many other jurisdictions, the question of protective gear usage plays a critical role in personal injury claims arising from motorcycle and other vehicular accidents. The extent to which a victim has used protective gear can significantly influence the outcome of a claim, affecting everything from the determination of liability to the calculation of damages. This article explores how wearing—or not wearing—protective gear can impact the legal proceedings and compensation outcomes of accident claims in North Carolina.

motorcycle accident attorneys North Carolina

Understanding Protective Gear Laws in North Carolina

North Carolina law mandates that all motorcycle riders and their passengers wear helmets that comply with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) 218. This law is not just a safety regulation—it can also significantly impact legal claims related to motorcycle accidents. Helmets are proven to reduce the severity of head injuries and are a critical factor in accident survivability rates. Besides helmets, other protective gear such as jackets, gloves, pants, and boots, though not mandated by law, are highly recommended as they provide additional protection and can mitigate injuries in the event of an accident.

Protective Gear and Its Impact on Personal Injury Claims

  1. Liability and Negligence
    • Comparative Negligence: North Carolina adheres to a strict contributory negligence rule, which can bar recovery if a plaintiff is found even slightly responsible for their own injuries. In cases where a motorcyclist or bicyclist isn’t wearing a helmet or other protective gear, defense attorneys often argue that the plaintiff contributed to their own injuries. However, this argument might only be applicable if the injuries sustained are of a type that protective gear could have mitigated. For example, if a motorcyclist not wearing a helmet suffers a head injury, contributory negligence might be claimed. Conversely, if the injuries are to an area of the body that would not have benefited from protective gear, such as a broken leg, this argument holds less weight. Obviously, where there are mitigating circumstances the cases and subsequent claims may become more problematic, hence it’s our recommendation to always retain the services on an experienced motorcycle accident attorney for handling these cases
  2. Insurance Considerations
      • Insurance Adjustments: Insurance companies often scrutinize the use of protective gear when adjusting claims. A claimant’s failure to wear legally required gear like helmets can affect settlements, with insurers potentially offering lower settlements if they determine that the lack of protective gear contributed to the injury severity.

motorcycle accident lawyers NC


Case Studies and Legal Precedents

Several cases in North Carolina have highlighted the importance of protective gear in accident claims. For instance, in cases involving motorcyclists who suffered severe head injuries but were not wearing helmets, courts have often found a percentage of fault with the rider, significantly affecting the outcome of the case. These decisions underscore the critical role that protective gear plays not only in safety but in legal recoveries post-accident.

Best Practices for Riders

  • For Riders: Always wear protective gear, especially those items mandated by law. Doing so not only enhances your safety but also strengthens your legal standing in the event of an accident.

The role of protective gear in accident claims in North Carolina is a pivotal issue that can determine the course of legal proceedings and the extent of compensation. Riders should prioritize safety through the consistent use of helmets and other protective gear, not only to protect themselves physically but also to safeguard their rights to full legal recovery in the event of an accident. Legal professionals will meticulously assess and present the implications of gear usage or its absence to effectively support their client’s claims.

For more information on safety regulations and legal guidelines related to protective gear usage in North Carolina, please visit the North Carolina Department of Transportation’s official website NCDOT, which provides resources and updates on current laws and safety tips, and if you need legal representation following a motorcycle accident/injury, please reach out to one of our motorcycle accident attorneys at 1-800-ACCIDENT, or click on the image below to schedule a free case evaluation.

Free consultation at Kellum Law Firm in North Carolina